­»´ä¤H¤å­õ¾Ç·|ºô­¶¡@http://www.arts.cuhk.edu.hk/~hkshp ¦è¤èªº¦L«×¦ò±Ð­õ¾Ç¬ã¨s¼¼µû¡]¤U¡^ B. K. Matilal µÛ ¼B¦t¥ú Ķ ¢».·ìÏɦ欣¤ÎªüÏi¹F¿i ¤j³¡¥÷·ìÏɦ欣(Yogacara)¨åÄy¡A¨Ò¦pµL¡÷(Asiga)¡B¥@¿Ë(Vasubandhu)¤Î¦w ¼z(Sthiramati)ªºµÛ§@³£¦b¤@¤E¤T¡³¦~¥N³Q¿ï½s¤Î½Ķ¥X¨Ó¡C³o¥]¬A½Ñ¦pªkµØ¡B·« ¦÷µ¥­«­nªº¤j­¼¸g¥çµM¡C³Ìªñ A. Wayman¤Ò°ü¥Xª©¤F³Ó°Ò¤Ò¤H¸g( Sri-Mala-Sutra) ªº­^Ķ¥»¡iµù28¡j¡C¥¦¥D­n¬O±j½Õ¦p¨ÓÂþǻ¡¡A¦Ó³o¦p¨ÓÂìO¤@²M²b¦Ó¤SÁô¦Ó ¥¼Å㪺·NÃÑ¡A¼çÂéó¨C¤@­Ó¤H¤¤¡A¤Hªº¥Ø¼Ð¥¿¦b©ó¹ê²{¦¹¤@¦ò©Ê¡C¹ï³o¨Ç²z½×ªº ¸Ô²Ó°Q½×¥i¨£©ó¨s³º¤@­¼Ä_©Ê½×( Ratnagotravibhaga)¡C°ª±Tª½¹D(J. Takasaki)ªºÄ_ ©Ê½×¬ã¨s¡iµù29¡j¡A¹ï³o¸g¨å§@¤F«D±`¦³»ù­Èªº¤ÀªR¡C¥L¤]¦Ò¹î¨ìªü¿à­C(alaya) ²z½×»P­LÂÃ(garbha)²z½×¶¡ªº¥i¯àÃö«Y(³o¤@ÂI¬O°lÀHLamotteªº¬Ýªk)¡A¤D­P©ó°ß ÃÑ©v¹ï«á´Á¤@¤¸½×§pÀȦh(Advaita Vedanta)ªº¼vÅT¡CReugg¤]¬°¾Ç¬É´£¨Ñ¤F¤@­Ó «D±`²`¨è¦Ó´I¾Ç³N»ù­Èªº¦p¨ÓÂòz½×±´°Q¡iµù30¡j¡C³o®Ñ¹ï¤é«á¥ô¦ó¦³Ãö­LÂà ¸Ñ²æ²z½×ªº¬ã¨s¨Ó»¡¡A¬Ò¬O¤£¥i©Î¯Êªº¡Cªø§À¶®¤H(M. Nagao)©ÒĶªº¤¤Ãä¤À§O½× (Madhyartavibhag n gasutra)¬O¬ã¨s°ßÃÑ©vÆ[©À½×ªº¥t¤@­«­nµÛ§@¡iµù31¡j¡C¦ý¹ï ©ó¸gÂó̭«­nªºÂ½Ä¶¡A¹ê²ö¹L©ó Lamotte©ÒĶªººû¼¯¸g(Vimalakirtin-irdesa)¡iµù 32¡j¡A¨º¤]¬O¦­¤w¦³¤H°Q½×¹Lªº¤F¡C S. Bagachi¥H·NĶªº¤è¦¡­^Ķ¥@¿Ëªº°ßÂäG¤Q¹|(Vimsatika)¡A¦ý¥i±¤ªº¬O¦¨ ÁZ¤£¬O«Ü²z·Q¡iµù33¡j¡CA. K. Chatterjee ¹Á¸Õ¹ï°ßÃÑ©v§@°ß¤ß½×­õ¾Ç­«ºc¡iµù 34¡j¡CChatterjee¥u¨Ì¿à±ë¤åªº¸g¨å¡A¦Ó§¹¥þ©¿µø¤F±q¤¤¤å¤ÎÂä奻Ķ¦^¦è¤è¤å ¦rªº¦n¨Ç­«­nªº°ßÃÑ©v¸g¨å¡AÃø©ÇD. Kalupahana §åµû Chatterjee¡A¦] A. K. Chatterjee ÅãµM¬O¿í±q Murti¸Ñ¦ò¾Çªº¸ô½u¡A¬G¦¹·í¥L¸àÄÀ¤¤Æ[®É¡A¤]´N¹J¤W Murti ©Ò¾D³{ªº§å§P¡CChatterjeeºÙ°ßÃÑ©v¬°µ´¹ï½×¨Ãµo®i¥L¦Û¤vªºµ´¹ï½×Æ[ ÂI¡A¥B±`¶D½Ñ±d¼w¡B¥ðÂӤζ®溸¡A¦ý«o¨S¦³¤Ó¦hªº±Òµo©Ê¡A¤Ï¦Ó¬O¥L¹ï¤@¤¸½× §pÀȦhªº¸ÑÄÀ¤Î¨ä»P°ßÃÑ©vªº¹ï¤ñÁٺ⦳§@¥Î¡C ³¯ºa±¶( W. T. Chan )«h¬°¥È¸Ë(Hsuan - tsang )ªº¦¨°ßÃѽ×(Cheng wei- shih lun)´£¨Ñ¤@­Ó«D±`¦³¥Îªº¿ïĶ¤ÎµùÄÀ¡iµù35¡j¡C¦¨°ßÃѽץ]¬A¥@¿Ëªº°ß ÃѤT¤Q¹|(Trimsika)¤Î¥È¸Ë¥D­n¨Ì¾ÚÅ@ªk(Dharmapala)µù¸Ñ©Ò¸àÄÀªº¤T¤Q¹|¹| ¤å¡A³¯ºa±¶¹ï°ßÃÑ­õ¾Çªº±´°QÁö»á²²¤¡A¦ý¥Lªºµù¸Ñ­Ë«Ü¦³¥Î¡CMatilal ¹ï¥@¿Ë ¡u°ßÃÑ¡v(Consionsness-only )¾Ç»¡ªº­õ¾Ç½×ÃÒ¡A¼g¤F¤@½g²­nªºµû½×¤å³¹¡iµù36¡j¡A ·í¤¤¥B´£¥Ü¥¦­Ì»P³¯¨º(Din aga)ªºÆ[©Ò½t½t½×(Alamhanapariksa)¤§¶¡ªº³sô¡C¥L ¤]«ü¥X³¯¨º¡EªkºÙ¾Ç¬£(Dinnaga - Dharmakirti School )ªº¡u¦ÛÃÒ¥÷¡v(sva-samvitti) ¾Ç»¡»P¥@¿Ëªº¡u°ßÃÑ©Ê¡v(Vijnapti-matrata)¤§¶¡ªº¤À§O¡C¥@¿Ë¡B³¯¨º¤ÎªkºÙ (Dharmakirti)¤T¤H´£¥X¤¶¥G¤@¤è­±¬O¦ò±Ð¡A¥t¤è­±¬O¥¿²z³Ó½×®v(Nyaya-Vajsesika) ¤Î¥jº¿²z©Ô(Kumarila)¤§¶¡¡A¹ïª¾Ãѽ׻P¦s¦b½×»á¬°ºëªöªº½Ø½×¡C¦^ÅU³o¨t¦Cªº µo®i¬O¬Æ­Ñ­õ¾Ç·N¸qªº¡C¬ã¨s³o¤@¶¥¬qªº¦L«×­õ¾Ç¥v¡A©e¹ê¥i¨Ï¤µ¤Ñ¦³³Ð³y¤Oªº ­õ¾Ç®a±o¯q¤£²L¡AMatilal«K¤w¦b«e¤@¶µ¤u§@¤WÀò±o¤@¨Ç¦¨ªG¡iµù37¡j¡CE. Sarachchandra ªº¤@½g¦³½ì½×¤å¡A±q¬¥§J(J. Locke)¡B¬f§JµÜ(G. Berkeley)¤Î¥ðÂÓªº ­^°ê¸gÅç½×(British Empiricism)Æ[ÂI¨Ó¹ï¦ò±Ð¦³Ãö¡u¥~¦b¥@¬É¡vªº²z½×¶i¦æ§å§P ©Êªº¦Ò¹î¡iµù38¡j¡C ¹ï©ó¡uªü¿à­C¡v(alaya )°ÝÃD¡AE. Frauwallner ¦³¤@­Ó­«­nªº½×¤å¡A°Qªü¿à­C ÃÑ( alayavijnana)¤Î©a¼¯Ã¹ÃÑ(amala-vijnana)¤§¶¡ªºÃö«Y¡iµù39¡j¡C¦¹¥~¡AL. Schmithausen ±NÂÃĶ·ì¦÷®v¦a½×¡u¯Iºn«~¡vĶ¡Bµù¬°¼w¤å¡A¨Ã¼g¦³¤@¾Ç³N¬ã¨s ¡iµù40¡j¡CH. V. Guenther ¬O¦ì¦h²£ªºµÛ­zªÌ¡A±Mªø©ó¦èÂðßÃѾǤΦò±ÐÀq«´ ¥D¸qªº¬ã¨s¡C¥L¤O¥D¦èÂæò±Ð¬O¤@¿W¥ß¨t²Î¡iµù41¡j¡A¬J¯à°÷¡A¤]À³¸Óµø¬°§@ ¯à¿W·í¤@­±¡A¥L¤]¥t¾ð¤@¼m¦a»{¬°Áa¨Ï¦b¤í¯Ê±ë¤å­I´ºªº±¡ªp¤U¡A¤´¥i²z¸Ñ¦èÂà ¦ò±Ð¡C¨ä¹w³]ªº«e´£¬O¦èÂù¬«Q¦Û¦æ³Ðµo³\¦h·sµü©Î·s·§©À(¨ä¹êÀ³»¡¬O¦b¦L«× ³N»y¤W¥[¶i·s¸q¡^¡F©Ò¥H¦pªG§Ú­Ì¥Î¦L«×¤j­¼«ä·Q¨Ó²z¸Ñ¦èÂæò±Ð¡A±N·|³y¦¨»~ ¸Ñ¡C³o¤@ÂI¤Þµo«D±`¤jªºª§Ä³¡A¦ýGuenther ¨Ã¨S¦³²M·¡¥æ¥N¦èÂæò±Ð³o¤@¯SÂI ¥H¥­®§¯Éª§¡C¦¹¥~¡A·í¥L§â¦èÂóN»y­^Ķ®É¦]¦r²´¼Ò½k¡A¦Ó¨Ï¦èÂæò¾ÇÅܱo¶O¸Ñ¡A ¦]¦¹©Û­P§åµû¡C¦AªÌ¡A¥L¸g±`¤Þ¾Ú¥¬¬¥(C. D. Broad )¡A¤×¨ä¬O¥Lªº¤ßÆF¤Î¨ä¦b¤j ¦ÛµM¤¤ªº¦ì¸m¨Ó¸àÄÀ¦ò±Ð¡A¥i±¤ªº¬O¡A³o¹ï©ó²z¸Ñ¦èÂæò±Ð¦Ó¨¥¦ü¤´µL¸É©ó¨Æ¡C ¤£¹L¡AGuenther ¦³¨â³¡»á¬°­«­nªºµÛ§@¡A¤@ªÌ¬O¾Ú¦L«×§÷®Æ¨Ó°Q½×ªüÏi¹F¿i­õ ¾Ç¤Î¤ß²z¾Ç¡iµù42¡j¡C¨ä¦¸¬O¤@½g¦³Ãö¦ò±ÐÀq«´¥D¸qªº½×¤å¡iµù43¡j¡C¦¹¤@µÛ ­z»á¬°Â²¼ä¡C ¬Û¹ï¦Ó¨¥¡A¹ïªüÏi¹F¿iªº¬ã¨s«h«Ü¦³­­¡A°£«e­zªºGuentherªüÏi¹F¿i¬ã¨s ¥~¡AÁÙ¦³W. RahulaªºÀ±°ÇªüÏi¹F¿i¶°½×(Abhidharmsamuccaya)ªk¤åĶµù¡A¥¦Â× ´I¤F¦ò±Ðªº­õ¾Ç¬ã¨s¡CK. Venkataramanan¹ï¾Ç¬Éªº°^Äm¬O¥L±N¤@¤Á©Ò¶Q³¡ (Symmitiya School )ªº¨Ì¤î¯ë­Y½×(Asrayaprajnaptisatra)±qº~Ķ¥»ÂàĶ¬°­^¤å¡iµù 44¡j¡CP.S. Jaini­º¦¸¥Xª©¤FªüÏi¹F¿i¿O½×(Abhidharmadipa)¡C¥¦¬O§åµû­ÑªÙ½× (Abhidharmakosa)ªºµÛ§@¡CP. S. Jaini¤]¼g¦³¤@­Ó¸Ô²Óªº¡u¾É¨¥¡vÀ°§U¾\Ū¡iµù 45¡j¡CSanti Bhiksu±q¤¤¤åÂàĶ¨â³¡ªüÏi¹F¿i½×¨å¡Gµo´¼½×(Jnanaprasthana)¤Îªü Ïi¹F¿i¥ÌÅS¨ý½×(Abhidharmrta)¡CNanamoli½ĶH. Warren¤ÎD. Kosambi ¦b1950 ¦~©Ò½sªº²M²b¹D½×¤¤ªº½t°_²z½×¡iµù47¡j¡CD. Khemindra Thera¤Î¨ä¥L¤H¤]­^ Ķ¥t¤@³¡­«­n¨åÄy¡G¸Ñ²æ¹D½×(Vimuttimagga)¡C ¦³Ãö¦ò±Ð±Kªk(Tantric Buddhism )¤è­±¡AS. B. Dasguptaªº¨â³¡±M®Ñ«D±`¦³±Ò µo©Ê¡iµù48¡j¡A¬Ò¬O¥HÀu¨q¾Ç¾i¬°°ò¦¡CD. Snellgrove ­è½Ķ¤j´dªÅ´¼ª÷­è¤ý ¸g(Hevajra-Tantra)¡A¨Ã½×¤Î±K­¼(Tantrayana)ªº­õ¾Ç¾Ç»¡¡iµù49¡j¡C¤j­¼ªº¡u©Ê ªÅ¡v¡B¡u¯ë­Y¡v(prajna)­n¦p¦ó³sµ²©ó±K±Ðªº¥Ø¼Ð¤]¬O¦³½ìªº½ÒÃD¡C T. Ling«h¹ï¦ò±Ð¨ú¤@­Ó«Ü¤£¦Pªº¶i¸ô¡C¥L»{¬°¦ò±ÐÀ³³Qµø¬°¤H¹D¥D¸q (humanistic)ªºªÀ·|­õ¾Ç¡A¨Ã¥B­Ý¦³¬Fªv¤Î¸gÀÙ¤Wªº¦V«×¡A¨Ã¥D±i³o¤~¬O¹ï¦ò±Ðªº ¾A·í²z¸Ñ¡C©Ò¥HºÙ¥¦¬O¡u­Ó¤H©v±Ð¡v¤Ï¦Ó¬O¤@ºØ§á¦±¡ALing¹ï¦ò±Ðªº²z¸Ñ»á¨Ï ¤H¡÷°g¡C³o®£©È¤£¬O»P¥L­Ó¤Hªº¨ú¦VµLÃö¡iµù50¡j¡C ¢¼.³¯¨º»P±ß´Á¦ò±Ð¦]©ú¶q½× ³¯¨º(¥|¥@¬ö)¬O¦L«×­õ¾Ç¨ä¤¤¤@­Ó³Ì¨ã­ì³Ð©Êªº­õ¾Ç®a¡A¯S§O¦b¦³Ãö¶q½×¤Î ¦]©ú¾Çªº°ÝÃD¤W¡AµM¦Ó¡A¨ì©³¥L¬OÄÝ©ó°ßÃÑ©vªº©Î¬O¸g¶q³¡(Sautrantika)«h®£©È ¥Ã¬O¤£¸Ñ¤§Á¼¡A¥i±¤ªº¬O¡A©Ò¦³¥L¼gªº±ë¤å­ì¨å¬Ò¤w´²§H¡CªA³¡¥¿©ú(M. Hattori) ¹ï¾Ç¬Éªº¥\³Ò¬O¥L¾ÚÂäåĶ¥»ªº³¯¨º¶°¶q½×(Pramanas amuccaya)¡u²{¶q«~¡v­«ºc ³¯¨º¾Ç»¡¡C¥L¹ï³¯¨ºªºµÛ­z§@¥X«D±`ÄYÂÔªºÂ½Ä¶¤Îµù¸Ñ¡A¨Ã¦bµùÄÀ¤¤°Q½×¤F¦n¨Ç ­«­nªº­õ¾Ç°ÝÃD¡iµù51¡j¡C E. Frauwallner¹ï©ó³¯¨º¤Î¥@¿Ëªº¦]©ú¾Ç¬ã¨s¤]¦³¤£¥i©¿²¤ªº°^Äm¡C¥@¿Ëªº ¦]©ú½×¨å¤]¬O´²§H¡CFrauwalner¬ã¨s½×ÅGªk(vada)«á´Áªºµo®i¤Î±q¦³»ù­ÈªºÂ_² ´Ý³¹¤¤­«ºc¤F¥@¿Ë¦b½×­y(Vadavidhi)ùتº©Ò¦³®Ú¥»½×ÂI¡C¾ÚE. Frauwallner »¡¡A ½×­y¦b«Ü¦h¦a¤è³£»á¬°ªñ¦ü³¯¨ºªº¥¿²zªù½×(Nyayamukha )¡A¦ý³¯¨ºªº¤Ñ¤~¨Ï¥L ¦b¥@¿ËªºÅé¨t¤W¥[¤W¦]½ü»¡(hetucakra)¡iµù52¡j¡C³¯¨ºÀ³¦b«Ø¥ß¡u¦]½ü»¡¡v¤W°O ¦³¤@¥\(¨º¬O¤EºØ¥i¯à±À²zªºÅé¨t)¡A¦]¨º¬O¦L«×¦]©ú¾Çµo®i¤W«Ü­«­nªº¤@¨B«e ¶i¡C»ô«ä¶M(R. C. Y. Chi)¥H¥¬¹ç(Boolean)ªº¥N¼Æ¡B­S¤ó(J. Venn's)¹Ïªí¤Î²{¥N§Î¦¡ Å޿誺·§©À¥þ­±çE®i¥X³¯¨ºªº¦]½ü»¡¤ÎÅã§@½×®v(Uddyotakra)ªº¦]½ü»¡(¬O«eªÌ ªºÂX¤j)¡C¥Lªº¬ã¨s¹ï¤µ¤é¦³³Ð³y¤Oªº­õ¾Ç®a¨Ó»¡¬O¤Q¤À¦³·N¸qªº¡CÁöµM³o®Ñ¤§ ¤¤¦³¨Ç»á¥iª§Ä³¤§³B¡A¦ý¾ãÅé¨Ó»¡¡A¥¦­Ì¤´¬°®É¤U¬ã¨sÅ޿誺­õ¾Ç¥»½èªÌ±a¨Ó¬} ¨£¡iµù53¡j¡C E. Frauwallner ªº³¯¨º¡G¥LªºµÛ§@¤Î¨äµo®i¡iµù54¡j¬O³¯¨º¬ã¨s»â°ì¤ºªº­« ¤j°^Äm¡C¥¦»¡©ú³¯¨º«ä·Q¥Ñ½×ÅG­y½dªº¯U¯¶½d³ò¦p¦óÂàÅܬ°ª¾ÃѽװÝÃD¡A¤D­P©ó ³¯¨º¶°¶q½×¦p¦ó§¹¦¨¦]©ú¾Ç»P¶q½×¤§¶¡ªº­«­nµ²¦X¡C¥L¤]»¡©ú©Þ¦Ü¶F±ù (Bhartrhari)¤Î¦ò±Ð¸g¶q³¡¦p¦ó²`¨è¦a¼vÅT³¯¨ºªº­õ¾Ç«ä·Q¡CB. K. Matilal«hª`·N ³¯¨ºªº¡u¤F§O¡v(vikalpa)©Î¡u·§©À«Øºc¡v(conceptual construction)»P©Þ¦Ü¶F±ù¤§¶¡ ªº±K¤Á³sô¡iµù55¡j¡C³¯¨º³Ì­«¤jªº³Ð¨£¡G¡u¾B°£¡v(apoha)²z½×»P¡u«Øºc¡v²z ½×¬O¤¬¸Éªº¡CÂǥѳo¤@¾Ç»¡¡A¥i¥H²Ê²¤¦aÁA¸Ñ¡u§_©w¡v©Î¡u±Æ¥¸¡v¤§·§©À¡C¦Ó¡u¾B °£¡v¾Ç»¡«h¼vÅT¤F«á´Áªº¦ò±ÐµÛ­z®a¡AÁöµM¥L­Ì¹ï¸Ó¾Ç»¡ªº¸àÄÀ¤£¨£±o¬O©¼¦¹¶¡ ¥þµLª[²§¡C¡u§_©w¡v¤§Æ[©À¯A¤Î¡u¾B°£¡v¾Ç»¡¡A³o¹ê¬O¤@­ÓÃøÃD¡CB. Matilal »{ ¬°¡A¦¹¤@¡u§_©w¡v¨Ã¤£¬O¤@¯ëÅÞ¿è¾Ç¤Wªº¡u§_©w¡v¡C¦ý³o«o¬O¦ò±Ð¯S¦³ªº¡u§_©w¡v ·§©À¡A§Y¡G§_©wªº¡uªÖ©w¡v¸q§¹¥þÁõÄÝ©ó§_©wªº¡u§_©w¡v¸q(Ķ«ö¡G§Y¥uªÖ©w¡G ¡uX¤£¬O¤°»ò¡v¡A¦ý«o¤£¯A¤ÎªÖ©w¡uX¬O¤°»ò¡v)¡C¨Æ¹ê¤W¡A³¯¨º²z½×¤]³\¤´¦³ ¨ÇÆ[ÂI¯à´£¨Ñµ¹²{¥Nªº°ß¦W½×(nominalism)¡iµù56¡j¡C H. Herzberger¹Á¸Õ¹ï«Ø°ò©ó¡u¹w³]ªº¥i¤ÀÂ÷©Ê¡v(detachability of presuppositions)²z½×¤Wªº¡u¾B°£¦¡(apohist)§_©w¡v§@¥X¤@§¹¾ãªºçE³¯¡iµù57¡j¡C ³o¬ã¨s»¡©ú¤@­Ó¥y¤l¯à³Q¤À¸Ñ¬°¨â­Ó²Õ¦¨³¡¥÷¡G¹w³]ªº¤Î©ú¨¥ªº¤º®e¡A¦Ó©Ò¦³ÄÝ Æ[©À©Êªº¨Æª«¬Ò¯à³Q¥]¯Ç¶i¹w³]ªº°ò¦ùØ¡C³o¬O¡uÅÞ¿è¤ñ¸û¬ã¨s¡v»â°ì¤º¡A¤@­Ó ¦³»ù­Èªº³Ð·s¡C¦bªñ´Áªº¤@½g½×¤åùØ¡AªA³¡¥¿©ú½×ÃÒ¸g¶q³¡ªº°²¦W»¡(prajnapti- sat)¡A©Î¤ª¡u°ß¦W°²¦³¡v(nominal existence )¬O³¯¨º¡u¾B°£¡v½×ªº°ò¦¡C¡iµù58¡j ¨ü¨ì³¯¨º¦]©ú¾Çªº¼vÅT¡A²M¿ë(Bhavaviveka)¦b¤¤Æ[¨t²Î¤ºµo®i¥X¦Û¥ß½×ÃÒ¬£ (Svatantrika school )¡C¥L»{¬°°£¤FÂkÂÕ½×ÃÒ(prasanga)¥~¡A¤]¥i¥H¾Ú³¯¨ºªº©w¸q¨Ó «Ø¥ß¤T¬q½×¥H½×ÃÒ¡u©ÊªÅ¡v¾Ç»¡¡C¾ÇªÌ­Ì¨Ã¤£¤Ó¦b·N©ó²M¿ë¤§»¡¡A¦ý¬O §À¤s¶¯ ¤@(Y. Kajiyama)«o¦³¨â½g½×­z²M¿ë­õ¾Çªº¦³½ì½×¤å¡iµù59¡j¡C §À¤s¤óĶµù±ß´Á ¦ò±Ð¦]©ú¾Çªº¤@­Ó­«­nµÛ§@®a¸Ñ²æÅ@(Mokskargupta)ªºµÛ§@¡iµù60¡j¡C §À¤s¤ó ²­n¦a°Q½×¤@­Ó­«¤jªº­õ¾Ç°ÝÃD¡A§Y³¯¨ºªº¡u¦³¬Û¡v(akara)ÃÑ»P¨ä¥L¦ò±Ð­õ¾Ç®a ªº¡uµL¬Û¡vÃѤ§¶¡ªº¹ï¥ß¡C¦AªÌ¥L¤S¼g¹L¤@½g½×¤å¥h°Ï§O¦b¦ò±Ð¤Î¦L«×­õ¾ÇùØ¡uªÖ ©w¡v¤Î¡u§_©w¡v¨â­Ó·§©Àªº·N¸q¤D­P¨ä¨âºØ¯S©Ê¡iµù61¡j¡C ¥_¤t¨q«h(H. Kitagawa)¦b¤@½gµu¤å¡A°Q½×³¯¨º¦]©ú¾Ç»Pªü¨½¤h¦h¼w²z«h¾Çªº ¸g°|­õ¾Ç(Scholastic)¦¡¸àÄÀ¤§¶¡ªº¤À§O¡iµù62¡j¡C¤£¹L¥_¤t¤ó³Ì¨ã¥Nªí©ÊªºµÛ §@«o¬O¥H¤é¤å¥Xª©ªº¡A¨º¬O³¯¨º¶°¶q½×ªº¡u¤ñ¶q³¹¡v¡CA. Kunst¤]¼g¤F¦n¨Ç¦³Ãö ¦ò±Ð¡u¤ñ¶q¡v¬ã¨sªº½×¤å¡iµù63¡j¡C¥Lªº¬ã¨s¬O¥H¦b³¯¨º¤§«áªº±IÀÃ(Santaraksita) ¬°¹ï¶H¡C°Q½×²z«h¾Ç¤¤ªº­«¤j½ÒÃD¡A¨Ò¦p±Æ¤¤«ß¤Î¤G¤¸¤T¬q½×(two-membered syllogism)¡C¦Ó¥Ã´I(M.Nagatomi)«h°Q½×ªkºÙªºÄÀ¶q½×(Pramanavarttika)ªº°ò¥»¬[ ºc¡iµù64¡j¡C¥L©ÒĶªºÄÀ¶q½×¤´¦b«¢¦òªF¤èÂO®Ñ­Ô´Á¥Xª©¡CMookerjee»Pªø±T (H. Nagasaki)¦XĶ¸Ó®Ñªº¡u¦Û¤ñ¶q¡v(Svarthnumana)³¹¡A¦ý¥uĶ¤F¶}ÀYªº¤­¤Q¤@¹| ¤ÎªkºÙªº¦Ûµù¡AĶªÌ¸Ôµù¨C¤@­Ó¯A¤Îªº°ÝÃD¡iµù65¡j¡CA. Malvania ²­n¦a¤À ªRªkºÙ¡u¦Û¤ñ¶q¡v³¹¡u¾É¨¥¡vªº¤º®e¡iµù66¡j¡C E. Steinkellner½s¿ï¦èÂ꺸g¨å¡A¨Ã¤p¤ßÂÔ·V¦a­«ºcªkºÙ¦]ºw½×(Hetubindu) ±ë¤å­ì¤å¡A¨º¬O°ò©ó S. Sanghavi¸û¦­®É¤~§¹¦¨ªº­«ºc¡iµù67¡j¦A§@­×§ï¦Ó¦¨ªº¡C E. Steinkellner¤]¬°¸ÓµÛ§@§¹¦¨¤@­Ó¼w¤åªºÄ¶µù¡iµù68¡j¡C»á¦³§U©ó²z¸ÑªkºÙ²` ¶øªºÆ[ÂI¡CT. Vetterª`·N¨ìªkºÙªº¥t¥t¤@­Ó­«­nµÛ§@¶q§à¾Ü½×(Pramanaviniscaya) ¡iµù69¡j¡A¨Ã½s¿ï¤FÂäå¸g¨å¡A¥B¦b¥t¤@­Ó¬ã¨s¤¤¦¬¶°¤Î¿ë§O¥X¦³¥Îªº±ë¤åÂ_ ²´Ý³¹¡iµù70¡j¡C¥L¹ïªkºÙªºª¾ÃѽסA¤Î¨ä»P¸g¶q³¡¦s¦b½×¡A¤D¦Ü¦­´Áªº¦ò±Ð ¶q½×(pramanas)¤§¶¡ªºÃö«Y§@¥X¤@­Ó¨t²Îµû½×¡C¥t¤@­Ó¹ïªkºÙªº­«­n¬ã¨sªÌ¡A¬O M. Gangopadhyaya¡C¥L®Ú¾ÚÂäåĶ¥»­«ºc±ë¤å¥»¡C¨Ã¥tĶµù½Õ¥ñ¤Ñ(Vinitadeva) ªºªkºÙ¥¿²z¤@ºw( Nyayabindu)µù¡C¦ÓH. N. Ganguly §@¤F¤@­Ó«D¤ñ´M±`ªº¹Á¸Õ¡A §Y¥HªkºÙ¡B¼z¥ú(Prajnakara)¤Î©Þ­P¶F±ù­õ¾Ç²z½×¥h¦Ò¹îÅÞ¿è¹êÃÒ½×(Logical positivism)ªº¾Ç»¡¡iµù71¡j¡A¦¹¤@¹Á¸Õ¤£¯àºâ±o¤W«Ü¦¨¥\¡A¥D­n¬O¦]¬°¥L¦b¤@­Ó ¤Óµuªº½g´TùØ¥]§t¹L¦hªº§÷®Æ¡C¨º¬O¤@­Ó«Ü¨ã³¥¤ßªº­p¹º¡A¦ý§@ªÌ¦ü¥G¾Þ¤§¹L «æ¡C Ä_ºÙ(Ratnakirki)¬O¤½¤¸¤Q¤@¥@¬öªº¤H¡C¥LµÛ¦³´X­Ó¬ã¨s¥h°Q½×¦ò±Ð¹ï­õ¾Ç¤Î ÅÞ¿è¾Ç¤Wªº¤@¨Ç°ÝÃDªºÆ[ÂI¡A¤£¹L¨Æ¹ê¤W¨º³£¬O¥L¦Ñ®v´¼³Ó¤Í(Jnanasrimitra)ªº¥ß ³õ¡C¼Æ¦ì²{¥N¾ÇªÌ¤]ª`·N¨ìÄ_ºÙ¡A §À¤s¶¯¤@½ĶÄ_ºÙ½×¡u¦]ªG©Ê¡v°ÝÃDªº­«­n ¬ã¨s¡iµù72¡j¡C¥L¤S¦b¥t¤@­Ó½×¤å¤¤Â½Ä¶Ä_ºÙ±q¦ò±ÐªºÆ[ÂI¹ï¿W§Ú½×(solipsism) ©Ò§@ªº»é¥¸¡iµù73¡j¡C D. Sharma ½ĶÄ_ºÙ½×¡u¾B°£¡vªº³¹¸`¡iµù74¡j¡C¦ÓA. C. S. McDermott «hĶ¡u¹Mº¡¡v(vyapti)³¹¡A¡iµù75¡j¤W­z¤GĶ¦bºë½T©Ê¤W³£¤£¬O«Ü²z·Q¡C¦ý¬O¡A ´N²{¥N­õ¾Çªº¯ßµ¸¨Ó»¡¡A³o¨Ç¦³Ãö¤¤¥@¬ö¦ò±Ð¦]©ú¾Ç¤Îª¾Ãѽ׾ǻ¡ªº®Ñ¡A¨ä»ù­È ¹ê¤£³æ¦b©ó½Ķ¥»¨­¡A¦Ó¦b«ä·Q¤º®e¤W©Ò­Ñªº­ì³Ð©Ê¡CA. C. S. McDermott¯S§O ¼ô±x²{¥Nªº¼Æ²zÅÞ¿è(mathematical logic)¡A¦]¦Ó±NÄ_ºÙªº­õ¾Ç½×ÃÒ©w©Ê¬°¦è¤è¤À ªRªk¤¤ªº§Î¦¡¥D¸q¡CD. Sharma «h»{¬°¡u¾B°£¡v¨Æ¹ê¤W¬O¥H¡u©RÃDª¬ºA¡v (propositional attitude )ªº³N»y¨Ó§@¸ÑÄÀªº·N¸q²z½×¡C ¾ÚE. Frauwallner ¬ã¨s©Ò¥Ü¡A°Ó½~ù(Sankarsvamin)¬O¤½¤¸¤»¨ì¤C¥@¬öªº¤H¡A ¬O³¯¨ºªº¾Ç¥Í¡A¥LÅãµM©¾¹ê¦a¦b¥Lªº¦]©ú¤J¥¿²z½×(Nyayapravesa)¤¤³¯­z¤F¤D®v ªº¦]©ú¾ÇÅé¨t¡C¥ß¤tªZÂÃ(M. Tachikawa)½Ķ¥X¥LªºµÛ§@¡A±q¦Ó¦³§U©ó³¯¨º¦]©ú ¾Ç¬ã¨s¡iµù76¡j¡C 1992¦~5¤ë Ķ©ó Kitchener - Waterloo, Ontario 1997¦~1¤ë ­×¥¿©ó­»´ä Copyright (c) Hong Kong Society of Humanistic Philosophy. All Rights Reserved.